Understanding Scrap Value Before Tendering: One of the Most Overlooked Parts of Decommissioning and Demolition
Updated: 15 minutes ago

When clients think about the cost of a decommissioning and demolition project, they often focus on the obvious factors:
asbestos removal
hazardous materials management
demolition methodologies
waste disposal
temporary works
environmental remediation
However, one of the largest commercial variables on many industrial decommissioning and demolition projects is often sitting in plain sight.
Scrap metal.
Yet surprisingly few asset owners fully understand:
how much scrap metal exists within their asset
what the likely recovery value is
how scrap assumptions influence contractor pricing
who should carry the commercial risk associated with scrap recovery
These questions can significantly affect project costs, tender returns, risk allocation and contractor performance.
FEED Is About More Than Risk Reduction
Front-End Engineering Design (FEED) studies are often associated with risk reduction, project planning and engineering assessments.
Clients commonly use FEED to better understand:
hazardous materials
structural constraints
demolition sequencing
temporary works requirements
waste management strategies
While these are all critical, FEED can also provide valuable commercial intelligence.
Understanding waste quantities, recycling opportunities, disposal routes and scrap recovery potential can significantly improve the quality of tender information issued to the market.
The result is often improved cost certainty and more informed procurement decisions.
We discussed this topic in more detail in our previous article, FEED for Decommissioning and Demolition, where we explored how Front-End Engineering Design can significantly reduce uncertainty and improve project outcomes before tendering begins.
Why FEED Is Common in Construction but Rare in Demolition
Major construction projects routinely invest significant time and money in FEED studies before construction begins.
Yet decommissioning and demolition projects often proceed with significantly less information despite containing greater uncertainty, hidden conditions and higher levels of risk.
The question clients should ask is:
Why would we spend millions planning how to build an asset but comparatively little planning how to safely dismantle it?
Many industrial demolition projects involve decades of modifications, undocumented changes, ageing infrastructure, hazardous materials, retained assets and live operational interfaces.
Investing time and money during the FEED stage often allows clients to reduce uncertainty before approaching the market, resulting in better tender returns and fewer surprises during project execution.
Understanding What Is Actually On Site
Many industrial facilities contain significant quantities of valuable materials including:
carbon steel
stainless steel
copper cable
aluminium
brass
lead
electrical equipment
process plant components
Through site inspections, engineering reviews, drawings, asset records and physical surveys, it is often possible to develop reasonable estimates of:
steel tonnage
non-ferrous metal quantities
cable recovery quantities
processing requirements
recycling opportunities
likely recovery values
This provides clients with a much better understanding of the true value contained within their asset before demolition begins.
Without this analysis, both clients and contractors are often working with assumptions rather than evidence.

Scrap Value Is Only Part of the Story
Whilst scrap recovery can significantly influence project costs, it is only one side of the equation.
Clients also need to understand:
waste disposal costs
hazardous waste liabilities
asbestos waste volumes
contaminated land risks
recycling opportunities
transportation requirements
On many projects, the difference between a profitable outcome and a costly surprise is not simply understanding what materials can be sold, but understanding what materials will cost money to remove and dispose of.
The true commercial picture only becomes clear when both cost and value are understood.
Why Scrap Intelligence Matters During Tender Evaluation
One of the most valuable benefits of understanding scrap quantities is during the tender evaluation process.
Consider a scenario where three demolition contractors submit bids for the same project.
Contractor A estimates 8,000 tonnes of recoverable steel.
Contractor B estimates 12,000 tonnes.
Contractor C estimates 15,000 tonnes.
Without independent analysis, it can be difficult for a client to determine which estimate is realistic.
This matters because scrap recovery often forms a significant part of a contractor's commercial model.
If a contractor has substantially overestimated recoverable scrap value, they may effectively be losing money before the project has even started.
This can create commercial pressure throughout the project and potentially lead to:
claims and disputes
programme pressure
scope challenges
cost recovery attempts
reduced project stability
potential safety performance issues
Conversely, a contractor that significantly underestimates scrap value may appear more expensive during tender evaluation despite offering the most realistic assessment of the project.
Understanding the asset before tendering allows clients to evaluate bids with far greater confidence.
Who Should Carry the Scrap Risk?
On many decommissioning and demolition projects, scrap value risk is allocated directly to the demolition contractor as part of the commercial arrangement.
The contractor estimates the recoverable value of the scrap, incorporates that value into their tender and accepts the risk associated with future market fluctuations.
On the surface, this appears to be a simple solution.
However, the question clients should ask is:
Is this always the best approach?
The Impact of Market Volatility
Today's scrap markets can be highly volatile.
Global demand, energy prices, tariffs, shipping costs, geopolitical events and steel production levels can all influence scrap values.
A project tendered today may not commence for six, twelve or even eighteen months.
By the time scrap is actually recovered, market conditions may look very different.
When contractors are expected to carry all of the scrap market risk, they inevitably price that uncertainty.
This often results in:
reduced scrap value assumptions
increased contingency allowances
higher tender prices
greater commercial risk premiums
The irony is that the client often pays for much of this uncertainty through increased project costs.
Could the Client Retain the Risk?
An alternative approach is for the client to retain ownership of the scrap and receive the value directly.
This provides several advantages:
greater transparency
visibility of actual recovery values
reduced contractor assumptions
improved tender comparability
However, it also means the client is exposed to market fluctuations and may require additional administration and oversight.
For some organisations this may be entirely appropriate.
For others it may not align with their commercial objectives.
Is Risk Sharing a Better Solution?
Increasingly, some asset owners are exploring mechanisms that share scrap risk between both parties.
Examples include:
gainshare and painshare arrangements
agreed baseline scrap values
index-linked adjustment mechanisms
open-book recovery models
These approaches can reduce contractor contingency while still providing incentives to maximise recovery and recycling performance.
More importantly, they help align the interests of both parties rather than creating a situation where one side is effectively speculating on future commodity prices.
There is no single correct solution.
The most appropriate approach will depend on the client's objectives, appetite for risk and understanding of the asset.
There Is No One-Size-Fits-All Solution
There is no universal approach to scrap ownership and risk allocation.
Every decommissioning and demolition project is different.
The most appropriate commercial model will depend on several factors, including:
the size and complexity of the asset
estimated scrap value
market conditions
programme duration
client appetite for risk
contractor capability
procurement strategy
On some projects, transferring the risk to the demolition contractor may be entirely appropriate.
On others, the client may benefit from retaining ownership of the scrap and receiving the recovery value directly.
In certain circumstances, a shared-risk model may offer the best balance between commercial certainty and exposure to market fluctuations.
The important point is that the decision should be informed by data rather than assumptions.
Understanding likely scrap quantities, recovery values, processing requirements and market exposure allows clients to make informed decisions about the commercial structure that best supports their project objectives.
This is another area where FEED studies and independent Owner's Engineer support can provide significant value.
By understanding the asset before tendering, clients can assess the advantages and disadvantages of different commercial models and select an approach that aligns with their objectives, risk appetite and procurement strategy.
The goal is not simply to allocate risk.
The goal is to allocate risk to the party best placed to manage it.
Why Asset Intelligence Matters
Before deciding who should carry the risk, clients first need to understand what is actually present on site.
This means understanding:
material types
estimated tonnages
metallurgy and material quality
processing requirements
recovery rates
likely market value ranges
retained assets
live services
operational interfaces
Without this information, discussions around scrap ownership and risk allocation are largely based on assumptions.
With it, clients can make informed decisions about procurement strategy, risk allocation and commercial structure.
Turning Information Into Certainty
This is where a robust FEED study and independent Owner's Engineer support can provide significant value.
By understanding:
hazardous materials
waste streams
recycling opportunities
scrap inventories
demolition sequencing
retained assets
live interfaces
project constraints
clients can issue higher-quality tender information to the market.
Contractors can then price the project with greater confidence and fewer assumptions.
The result is often:
improved tender quality
reduced commercial uncertainty
greater cost certainty
more realistic programmes
safer project delivery
better overall project outcomes
Information Creates Certainty
The most successful decommissioning and demolition projects are rarely those with the lowest tender price.
They are the projects where the client has invested sufficient time and effort understanding:
hazardous materials
waste streams
retained assets
demolition constraints
scrap inventories
recycling opportunities
project risks
before approaching the market.
The better the information issued to tenderers, the fewer assumptions contractors are forced to make.
Fewer assumptions typically lead to:
more accurate pricing
reduced commercial risk
improved programme certainty
safer delivery
fewer surprises during execution
Whether scrap risk is retained by the client, transferred to the contractor or shared between both parties, the quality of the decision will ultimately depend on the quality of the information available.
Understanding the asset before tendering allows clients to make informed commercial decisions rather than relying on assumptions, contingencies or market speculation.
Ultimately, FEED is not simply about understanding risk.
It is about turning information into certainty.
And in decommissioning and demolition projects, certainty is often one of the most valuable commodities a client can buy.




Comments