In brief
Circulis Group (formerly JAMES Ltd) supported the owner of a high-risk UK chemical site through decommissioning and demolition during a phased closure. The owner’s priority was cost certainty, so significant scrap revenues from special metals and large ferrous volumes were included in fixed-price tenders. Amended ICE 7th edition conditions were developed with the owner’s legal team, and the only variations were works the client added.
Project at a glance
SECTOR
Chemical manufacturing
LOCATION
United Kingdom
PROJECT TYPE
Decommissioning and demolition of a chemical site undergoing phased closure
OUR ROLE
Supported the client on decommissioning strategy, procurement and demolition contract management
Demolition contract
Fixed price, ICE Conditions of Contract 7th edition with tailored amendments, competitively tendered
Scrap approach
Scrap revenues included within fixed-price tenders
KEY OUTCOME
Variations limited to client-added works; demolition ahead of schedule when last reported
On this page
01 What did the client need from the project?
The client’s objective was cost certainty, but the site presented three challenges. Decommissioning scope could not be fully defined at concept stage, the materials on site had significant value, and an extensive portfolio of supplier and receiver contracts had to be exited in a timely manner.
02 How can decommissioning be budgeted before the scope is fully known?
Decommissioning costs at concept stage can vary because the true scope cannot yet be fully defined. Circulis helped the client define its decommissioning strategies during early planning, giving it a basis for establishing a provisional amount.
03 Should scrap value be included in a fixed-price demolition tender?
Scrap is a key component of demolition value, and here it was significant because of special metal values and large ferrous volumes. As cost certainty was the client’s priority, scrap revenues were included in the fixed-price tenders.
This transfers the scrap market position to the contractor. An owner seeking to benefit directly from recovery values might choose another approach, so the decision should follow the owner’s commercial objective.
04 Why amend a construction contract for demolition?
Standard construction conditions are not written with demolition in mind. Circulis proposed the Institution of Civil Engineers Conditions of Contract, 7th edition, with tailored amendments, and gave extensive input on clause changes with the client’s legal team to make sure they were fit for demolition.
The resulting fixed scope and price allowed the client to set provisions and reasonable contingencies with confidence.
05 How were tenders evaluated?
Competitive tendering followed the client’s procurement processes. Circulis supported the client in securing sealed, non-collusive bids and developed a review process that allowed bids to be compared on a like-for-like basis.
06 How were variations controlled?
All post-award variations had to be tied to verifiable client scope additions and approved through a controlled change process. The only variations came from works the client added outside the original plan, when the contractor was asked to remove stock materials previously reserved for other uses.
Valuations were reconciled with physical progress and benchmarked against milestones. Forecasts and cost performance were reviewed at structured cost review boards.
07 How was the site prepared for demolition?
End points for each process product were set through a risk-based decommissioning strategy, developed with the client and reflecting typical demolition contractor capabilities. Circulis reviewed and audited decommissioning activities against the designated end states, and plant condition records gave the contractor the information needed for planning.
Hazardous insulating material (HIM) surveys were let on a fixed-price basis and reviewed against HSG264. PCI and scope were developed through HAZDEM hazard reviews. Circulis also supported the client with regulator notifications and local authority engagement.
08 How were safety and quality managed during execution?
Safe systems of work passed through a multi-stage gate process for development, issue and execution. Circulis cross-checked that relevant hazards and site information had been considered, supporting duty holders in meeting their own responsibilities, and assisted with site briefings and on-site execution reviews.
09 How were programme and stakeholders managed?
Circulis developed a master programme covering the pre-demolition phases, decommissioning, procurement, execution, remediation design and close-out. The client developed the detailed decommissioning programme with Circulis oversight, and its milestones were achieved on target and aligned with demolition contract award.
A realistic programme was also essential commercially, because it told stakeholders when supplier and receiver contracts could be exited. The contractor’s programme was formally reviewed each fortnight, supported by daily and scheduled progress reviews.
Outcome
Results.What the client got.
3
Challenges at the outset: undefined scope, valuable materials and contract exits
ICE 7th
Edition of the ICE Conditions of Contract, amended for demolition
On target
Detailed decommissioning programme milestones
Ahead
Of schedule on demolition when last reported

The demolition programme was ahead of schedule when last reported.

Variations were limited to works the client added.

Scrap revenues were captured within fixed-price tenders in line with the client’s cost certainty objective.

The detailed decommissioning programme was achieved on target.
For asset owners
Lessons for asset owners
01
Settle your scrap objective before tendering
Cost certainty and direct exposure to recovery values point to different commercial approaches.
02
Expect to amend standard conditions
Construction forms need legal and demolition input to work well for demolition.
03
Link the programme to commercial exits
Supplier and receiver contracts depend on decommissioning dates being realistic.
04
Separate client changes from contractor scope
Late requests, such as removing stored materials, should go through the same change control as any other addition.


Client-side support
Where independent client-side support helps
Legal and procurement teams know contracts, but may not see demolition every day. A client-side engineer or project manager can translate demolition risk into practical contract terms, tender comparisons and change control.
United Kingdom
Dubai, United Arab Emirates


Home / Case Studies / Demolition cost certainty
UK
Decommissioning project management
Demolition project management
Chemical manufacturing
Chemical site demolition case study:
Securing cost certainty through scrap value and amended contract terms
How fixed-price tenders, scrap revenue and contract amendments written for demolition gave a UK chemical site owner greater cost certainty.
4 min read
United Kingdom
Circulis Group (formerly JAMES Ltd)

