In brief
Circulis Group (formerly JAMES Ltd) led decommissioning and demolition management for assets within a high-risk UK chemical complex undergoing phased closure. Two large enabling projects were identified early, the demolition was let as a fixed-price contract under an amended NEC4 Option A, and areas that could not be accessed at tender stage were allocated as risk items. Those risk items were the only variations to the demolition contract.
Project at a glance
SECTOR
Chemical manufacturing
LOCATION
United Kingdom
PROJECT TYPE
Decommissioning and demolition within a chemical complex undergoing phased closure
OUR ROLE
Led decommissioning and demolition management for the client
ENABLING WORKS
Major steam diversion; new modular permanent facilities for displaced engineering staff
DEMOLITION CONTRACT
Fixed price, NEC4 Option A with tailored amendments, competitively tendered
KEY OUTCOME
The only demolition contract variations were risk items allocated at tender stage

Home / Case Studies / Chemical complex demolition case study
UK
Decommissioning project management
Demolition project management
Chemical manufacturing
Chemical complex demolition case study:
Controlling variations through enabling works and risk allocation
How early enabling works, an amended NEC4 Option A contract and pre-agreed risk items kept demolition variations limited on a UK chemical complex.
5 min read
United Kingdom
Circulis Group (formerly JAMES Ltd)

On this page
01 What made this demolition project complex?
The demolition assets could not simply be isolated and removed. Their location and scope meant that a major steam diversion was needed, and engineering staff based in the demolition area had to be relocated before work could start.
Some areas also could not be accessed before tender, so information about them could not be gathered. A conventional fixed-price tender would have left that uncertainty to be argued over later.
02 How were the enabling works managed?
The enabling projects were identified early in the process, so they could be planned and funded ahead of demolition.
Circulis led a separate project to construct new modular permanent facilities for the displaced engineering staff. This construction was tendered separately from the demolition contract, which kept its costs distinct, and initial provisions were made so that construction could begin.
03 How was the decommissioning end state defined?
The decommissioning strategy was developed in partnership with the client. A risk-based approach set the decommissioning end point for each process product, combining the client’s plant and product knowledge with Circulis decommissioning procedures.
End state criteria also took account of what a typical demolition contractor is equipped to handle, so the plant would be handed over in a condition contractors could realistically work with.
Decommissioning activities were reviewed and audited against the designated system end states. Plant condition was recorded on system templates, giving the demolition contractor the information needed to plan the works. All handover documents were peer reviewed and signed off by the project team.
04 How was cost certainty achieved?
01 Fixed-price surveys
Circulis developed the scope of works for the hazardous insulating material (HIM) surveys so that prospective surveyors could offer fixed-price proposals. Surveys were compiled to match the defined demolition areas and reviewed against HSG264, with quantities justified to ensure HIMs were neither overstated nor understated.
02 A fixed-price demolition contract
Circulis recommended NEC4 Option A with tailored amendments, working regularly with the client’s procurement team to make sure the amendments suited demolition. The fixed scope and price allowed the client to set its provisions and reasonable contingencies. Demolition arisings were included within the contractor’s fixed price, a decision made jointly by the client and Circulis.
03 Risk items for inaccessible areas
Where scope could not be confirmed because of access restrictions, a risk allocation was developed at tender stage to take effect once access became possible. All other post-award changes would need to be verifiable client scope additions, approved through a controlled change process.
04 Valuation and cost reporting
Valuations were reconciled with physical progress and benchmarked against milestones. Forecasts and cost performance were reviewed at structured cost review boards with the client.
05 How were the tender and pre-construction information controlled?
Pre-construction information (PCI) and the scope of works were developed through hazard reviews, including HAZDEM, and signed off through committee review. Client information was collated and filtered so that the demolition contractor received what was relevant.
Competitive tendering followed the client’s procurement processes. Circulis supported the client in securing sealed, non-collusive bids and developed a review process that allowed like-for-like comparison.
Circulis also led formal regulator notifications and local authority engagement, and local authority conditions were reflected in the PCI and scope.
06 How were safety and quality managed during demolition?
Safe systems of work passed through a multi-stage gate process covering development, issue and execution. Circulis cross-checked that relevant site information and hazards had been considered in proposed scopes of work, supporting duty holders in meeting their own responsibilities.
Documents were reviewed jointly with the client. Circulis also assisted with site briefings, delivery of safe systems of work to the workforce and on-site execution reviews.
07 How were programme and stakeholders managed?
A master programme integrated the pre-demolition phases, decommissioning, contractor procurement, execution, remediation design and site close-out, and was adapted as the project developed. The critical path was identified and managed throughout.
The detailed decommissioning programme met its milestones on target and stayed aligned with the demolition contract award. During demolition, the contractor’s programme was formally reviewed each fortnight, with daily and scheduled progress reviews.
Circulis led stakeholder consultation throughout, both to develop the PCI and scope and to keep those involved in the demolition sequence informed.
WHO WE ARE
Results.What the client got.
2
Large enabling projects identified early and run separately
NEC4 A
Fixed-price demolition contract with tailored amendments
HSG264
Guidance the hazardous insulating material surveys were reviewed against
On target
Detailed decommissioning programme milestones

The only variations to the demolition contract were the risk items allocated at tender stage.

The detailed decommissioning programme was achieved on target and aligned with contract award.

Enabling works were separated from the demolition contract and managed as distinct projects.

The client could set provisions and contingencies against a fixed scope and price.
For asset owners
Lessons for asset owners
01
Look for enabling works early
Services and occupied buildings within a demolition area can become projects in their own right.
02
Consider tendering enabling works separately
This keeps their cost visible and separate from the demolition price.
03
Price what you cannot yet see
Where access is restricted, agreeing how that risk is allocated at tender stage is better than discovering it during execution.
04
Set end states with the contractor in mind
Decommissioning criteria need to reflect what the demolition contractor can safely deal with.

case studies
More case studies
Decommissioning project management
Chemical manufacturing
How waste characterisation, staged funding and an open-book NEC4 alliance supported the demolition of mercury-contaminated chemical assets in the UK.
UK

